Critically examine how the ban on high-dose oral nimesulide reflects the application of the precautionary principle, risk–benefit assessment, and executive powers under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act in safeguarding public health.

Question

PocketIAS · Accepted Answer

* The ban on high-dose oral nimesulide reflects the application of core public health regulatory principles in a context of scientific uncertainty and patient safety concerns.

* **Precautionary principle:**

* Evidence linking nimesulide to hepatotoxicity, especially in children, emerged from adverse drug reaction reports and global regulatory actions.
  * Despite the absence of absolute causal certainty, the State acted to prevent potential irreversible harm, consistent with Supreme Court interpretations prioritising public health over commercial interests.

* **Risk–benefit assessment:**

* Therapeutic benefits of nimesulide as an analgesic and antipyretic were found to be comparable to safer alternatives like paracetamol and ibuprofen.
  * Risks, including acute liver failure at higher oral doses, outweighed marginal benefits.
  * Selective prohibition of high-dose oral formulations, rather than a total ban, demonstrates regulatory proportionality and clinical nuance.

* **Exercise of executive powers:**

* The Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940—particularly Section 26A—empowers the Central Government to ban drugs in public interest.
  * Decisions are informed by expert bodies such as the Drugs Technical Advisory Board, reflecting evidence-based delegated legislation.
  * Executive action allows timely intervention without legislative delay in health emergencies.

* **Limitations and concerns:**

* Weak post-market surveillance and uneven State-level enforcement reduce regulatory effectiveness.
  * Limited public disclosure of scientific rationale can affect transparency and trust.

* **Way forward:**

* Strengthening pharmacovigilance systems, periodic drug safety reviews, and risk communication mechanisms is essential.

Overall, the ban illustrates a balanced use of precaution, scientific evaluation, and statutory authority to safeguard public health.

✍️ Practice Mode

Write. Evaluate. Improve. Repeat.

The model answer is ready.

Comments (0)