Evaluate the impact of unconditional cash transfers on the economic empowerment of women in India. How do such programs affect overall fiscal sustainability?

Question

PocketIAS · Accepted Answer

Introduction Unconditional cash transfers (UCTs) aimed at women have emerged as a policy instrument to enhance household welfare and gender empowerment. Their impact, however, must be evaluated alongside implications for fiscal sustainability.

Impact on Economic Empowerment of Women

1. Enhanced Financial Inclusion Direct transfers into women’s bank accounts under schemes like PMJDY strengthen financial access, improve credit history and increase participation in formal financial systems.

2. Increased Bargaining Power and Autonomy Regular cash inflows improve women’s intra-household negotiating power. Studies from states like Odisha and Madhya Pradesh show higher decision-making roles in nutrition, schooling and small purchases.

3. Improved Human Capital Outcomes Cash in women’s hands is often prioritised for children’s health and education. Evidence from global pilots (e.g., Kenya, Brazil) indicates positive spillovers on household welfare that mirror Indian trends.

4. Limitations and Risks Without complementary interventions—skill development, labour-market access and social norms transformation—UCTs may not translate into long-term economic independence. There is also the possibility of reinforcing traditional caregiving roles rather than expanding employment prospects.

Impact on Fiscal Sustainability

1. Rising Revenue Expenditure Large-scale UCTs increase recurring fiscal commitments. Given India’s constrained tax-to-GDP ratio (around 11–12%), sustained funding may crowd out developmental expenditure.

2. Risk of Structural Fiscal Slippage Universal or broad-based transfers weaken adherence to medium-term fiscal targets and reduce fiscal space for capital investment, which has higher growth multipliers.

3. Dependency and Program Overlaps Multiple transfer schemes without rationalisation can create inefficiencies, reduce targeting effectiveness and pressure state finances disproportionately.

Way Forward A calibrated approach—targeting the most vulnerable women, linking cash with skill-building, ensuring digital transparency and maintaining fiscal discipline—can balance empowerment goals with long-term sustainability.

✍️ Practice Mode

Write. Evaluate. Improve. Repeat.

The model answer is ready.

Comments (0)