The proposed delimitation of Lok Sabha constituencies based on the 2011 Census exposes a fundamental tension between the principle of population-proportional representation and the imperatives of cooperative federalism. Discuss.

Question

PocketIAS · Accepted Answer

Introduction

Delimitation of Lok Sabha constituencies seeks to ensure equal representation based on population. However, using the 2011 Census raises concerns about its impact on cooperative federalism, particularly between northern and southern states.

Principle of Population-Proportional Representation

Ensures “one person, one vote, one value”, strengthening democratic legitimacy.
Reflects population shifts and migration patterns, correcting imbalances in representation.
Larger states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar may gain seats, aligning political power with demographic weight.

Tension with Cooperative Federalism

Southern states (e.g., Tamil Nadu, Kerala) that achieved population control risk losing representation.
Perceived as a disincentive for good governance, penalising states that implemented effective family planning.
May lead to regional imbalance in political power, straining Centre-State relations.
Fiscal federalism concerns may intensify, as political influence affects resource allocation.

Constitutional and Political Dimensions

Delimitation has been frozen since 1976 (extended to 2026) to protect states that controlled population growth.
Reopening it may revive north-south divides, affecting national integration.
Raises questions about balancing democratic equality with federal equity.

Way Forward

Consider a balanced formula combining population with other indicators (development, demographic performance).
Increase total Lok Sabha seats to avoid zero-sum redistribution.
Strengthen the Rajya Sabha’s federal role to offset imbalances.
Promote consensus-based reforms to uphold cooperative federalism.

Conclusion

Delimitation based solely on population risks undermining federal harmony. A nuanced approach is essential to reconcile democratic representation with the spirit of cooperative federalism.

✍️ Practice Mode

Write. Evaluate. Improve. Repeat.

The model answer is ready.

Comments (0)